why is civility important in politics

He pledged to look beyond red and blue and to discard the harsh rhetoric that characterizes our political debates. Civility has deep roots in the idea of respect for the individual.” See also Higgins v. Coatsville Area Sch. In his first speech as president-elect, Joe Biden made clear his intention to bridge the deep and bitter divisions in American society. So, how important is civility for democracy? NGOs and other groups can help to identify and train new types of leaders who have dealt with important public issues and can be recruited to run for political office at all levels and to serve in provincial and national cabinets. Empathy Is The Most Important Leadership Skill According To Research. The Institute for Civility in Government defines civility as “more than just politeness, although politeness is a necessary first step. It is about disagreeing without disrespect, seeking common ground as a starting point for dialogue about differences, listening past one’s preconceptions and teaching others to do the same. Jon Meacham, a presidential historian, says he was the most important person of 2020. This brief defines civility, examines its impact on government and state legislatures, and identifies strategies legislators use to strengthen civility in their legislatures. Workplace Civility - Importance. We are in a world that cannot … In an electoral democracy, protest provides an essential voice for minority groups. Use the important political context in the decade before the beginning of the American Civil War to develop an argument as to the real issues of the conflict between North and South. Which best describes a political party? By AIA NSW Legal Network Co-Convenor, Emirjona Gjana. Regardless of national origin, politics influence the daily lives of citizens from all socioeconomic backgrounds, races and ethnic origins. Bob Dylan’s work was at the forefront of the civil rights movement, with many songs directly influenced by current events. Civil liberties are the core of one's beliefs and a sense of peace. Moreover, social psychologists have attended to the importance of civil discourse vis-à-vis challenging topics such as … Civility holds moral implications and holds us back from operating on the “an eye for an eye” kind of reactionary, retaliatory behavior. Why Civility Matters — It Is The Essence . Civil and political rights are a class of rights that protect individuals' freedom from infringement by governments, social organizations, and private individuals. Headlee serves as an advisory board member for Procon and the Listen First Project. Twitter. It is important to be politically aware in order to have a better government. Civility in the workplace is important for employees to work in a nontoxic environment that has a positive effect on morale. the right to vote. Viewpoints. 07-4917, slip op. Provide food and minimizes famines. In fact, he notes, “Studies of this are pretty consistent: 95% of Americans think that incivility is a problem—in the world, the U.S., and their lives. The key to good crowdsourcing is not the volume of people, but the diversity of people in any dataset (e.g. After talking about the indirect causes of the Peloponnesian War between Athens and Sparta, it’s very important to explain the direct causes of the Peloponnesian War, in 434BCE, the democrats and oligarchs involved in a war against one another and that was in the city-state called Epidamnos, the Athens’ democrats asked Corcyra to help them, but the Corcyra refused … Some of us don't understand politics, and a lot of us have … this paper).. David Blankenhorn, of the Better Angels initiative, applies this same logic to improving … Equal rights to all. One critic called for a correction followed by a mass resignation. A former Whig, Lincoln ran on a political platform opposed to the expansion of slavery in the territories. Fewer chances of misuse of power. “Civil and political rights set out in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, as … In 2020, women’s annual earnings were 82.3% of men’s, although the gap is slowly improving. It's important in order to have an order in society. Over the years, his music has incorporated several styles including pop music, folk music, gospel, rock and even jazz. The Department of Justice, Peace and Human Development at the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops is introducing the Civilize It campaign Nov. 3 at parishes around the country. Civil right is the basic right to be free from unequal treatment, based on a certain religion, culture, gender, disability, and race. Social inequality, racial discrimination, economic disparity, poverty, and overpopulation are some of the major concerns of society today. Dr. This speech was important in several ways: It brought even greater attention to the Civil Rights Movement, which had been going on for many years. The Bible’s calls to love one’s neighbor should trump political concerns, wrote Ed Stetzer, the author of “ Christians in the Age of Outrage ,” in an email. Of the various ways in which citizens in the United States can be unequal, political inequality is- one of the most significant and troubling. However, the meaning of civility in political philosophy is much broader and it is considered to be a necessary virtue for the proper functioning of a secular democratic polity. The Bill of Rights was a controversial idea when it was proposed in 1789 because a majority of the founding fathers had already entertained and rejected the idea of including a Bill of Rights in the original 1787 Constitution. The first rule of George Washington’s “Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior in Company and … From historical movements such as the civil rights movement to current movements such as Black Lives … Basic rights of the person are protected. (Assuming that youre talking about the Americas civil war ) The civil war occured between the northen population and the south. Civility and Productivity. Political Culture Approach to the study of politics has made several important contributions to politics and comparative politics studies, which can be described as under: 1. Civil disobedience is a term coined by Henry David Thoreau. Participation proved successful in the Civil Rights Movement lead by Martin Luther King and later failed in the 1980s with the Equal Rights Amendment initiative. Why civility in politics won't be getting any better. Why would it be controversial to protect free speech, or the freedom from … But the term civil society may not exist in this name everywhere. People were involved in political organizations and community action groups because modern technology allowed more free time to society (Putman 2000). Noun. Why was the election of Abraham Lincoln important? Noun. Why freedom of speech was essential at that time should tell you that freedom of speech is vital and very important even in these modern days. Bad manners, disrespect and isolating behavior patterns are the building blocks of an uncivil environment and cause possibly irreparable damage to the business. This contribution is demonstrated best when one compares democratic governance in European countries with the situation in authoritarian regimes. The importance of these values is obvious to me. The same goes for important issues that are passed into law. It really is true that there’s been a decline in political civility in recent years. Nearly 130 years ago, in an interview with The Washington Post , R.J. Ingersoll noted, :True civilization is where every man gives to every other every right that he claims for himself." The people who are most likely to be affected by changes in legislation or political power, such as the poor, minorities and the disenfranchised, are the least likely to vote. In 2010, Allegheny College surveyed 1,000 randomly selected Americans nationwide to gauge attitudes on and perceptions of civility in politics and found that 60 percent of respondents felt that television news programs and radio talk shows contributed to the problem.. Further exacerbating the problem is the fact that liberals and conservatives tend to migrate to different … Slavery had polarized the United States politically and morally through most of the mid-nineteenth century. Others wanted the editorial board … As an organized social group, it is our duty to address these concerns and work towards the betterment of society. America is exceptional in the nature of its political divide. It is important to vote because many candidates for political offices are voted in by only one or two votes. Importance Of Politeness. Politeness is a way of being polite. It is a great virtue. It is a mark of discipline. It is behaving in a respectful and considerate manner towards other people. Every person wants to hear good things and see good behaviors towards themselves. Therefore it’s important to behave in a polite and pleasing way towards ... Civility in America 2019: Solutions for Tomorrow 8 POLITICAL LANDSCAPE TAKES A HIT AND INFLUENCES AMERICAN ACTIONS The vast majority of Americans agree that civility is important to our democracy (89%), and civility among our elected officials at all levels, including the presidential level, is equally important (92% and 91%, respectively). issues surrounding the legal right and ability to campaign and cast a vote in political elections. It would be impossible for a country to function smoothly if a political system was not in place to run it. In the past year alone, there have been countless incidents involving harassment and even assault of elected officials in the UK, and the constant background hum of petty bickering and name-calling. However, it performs certain important functions which help the administrative authority in various ways … Political parties are important in the US Congress, because party affiliation. Credits. It represents one of the most important documents in the field of minority rights: right to preserve one’s culture, tradition, language, religion and customs, right to educations in the native language, right to access to media, right to take part in economic, public and political life as well as to communication with the native people. None of us needed a poll to tell us why civility is important, but it is comforting to be reminded that we, the people, really do place a high value on it and want our politicians to embrace civility. But then a workshop led her to consider proving that violent resistance was more successful than the nonviolent kind. They ensure one's entitlement to participate in the civil and political life of the society and state without discrimination or repression. swing state. For most people living today, this decision might seem a little strange. Who started the Civil War and Why? In his essay from 1849, he defended his refusal to pay taxes because they paid for the state’s warfare and the upholding of slavery. Even so, Moore and other evangelical Christian leaders expect better behavior from the people in their pews. The right to privacy is a enshrined in article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), article 17 in the legally binding International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and in article 16 of the Convention of the Rights of the Child (CRC). The U.S Department of Labor recently published findings that would reinforce why ratification of the ERA is more important today than when it was originally passed by the Senate: Women Still Earn Less. Without politics, there would be no leaders, and without leaders, the country would definitely descend into totalitarianism or else anarchy. Relevance of Social Movements Social movements are important in societies because of their effectiveness to bring forth action. Q: How important is civility in American politics? Why Violence Works. Eighth, civil society can provide a training ground for future political leaders. However, development thinkers have gradually embraced a broader definition of development that includes people’s civil and political rights. By political equality we refer to the extent to which citizens have an equal voice over governmental decisions. Accountability of a civil servant In… Which is a primary goal of debates? 3. She had studied terrorism, civil war, and major revolutions — Russian, French, Algerian, and American — and suspected that only violent force had achieved major social and political change. Civil servants are the working arms of civil society specially for the legislatures. These important distinctions between voluntary, civil society and coercion-based government explain why political Max Kennedy-types are the rule rather than the exception. But political civility requires more than politeness and respectful listening; it also requires a realization that we must live together and ultimately compromise on some things where we differ in fundamental ways. Ability to express themselves. (“Civility is the sum of the many sacrifices we are called to make for the sake of living together” … During that time, we heard from the new mayor of Charlottesville, Va., on why she's wary of the very idea of civility; we reported on a gathering of political opposites trying to … But others understand why it's important and shocking and women, and their male allies, are coalescing in unprecedented ways to address the enormous gender imbalance in our government and the now glaringly obvious fact that the imbalance does us all -- particularly women, who make up more than half of the … Civility is significant and essential because it cements civilization. Why is civility so important? Also, once diversity is accepted, the society has a much higher chance to be internally and externally peaceful due to the lack of ignorance about other people. But beyond the current crisis, civil society is an essential building block of development and national cohesion. The result is tragic. ... “Why is equality important” is the topic of discussion. Diplomacy in the 21st Century and Why it is Important? Being polite and courteous is vital in society and in the workplace for everyone to get along. Political equality. to help voters understand public policy. Although civility has received limited attention in psychology, it has received considerable focus in other disciplines (Clark, 2013; Sarat, 2014). shapes the debate and controls legislative agenda. Some people may think as to why it impacts our lives. According to one of the greatest theorists of the democratic public sphere, the German philosopher Jürgen Habermas, not very. Social movements are a driving force for political, educational, healthcare, housing, employment and other government institutional changes. There definitely has been a decline in political civility in recent years. 1. Safe2Tell expects new challenges in the coming months. “We will probably start to see things like bullying increased as students return to the classroom, and potentially anxiety and depression. By Benjamin Ginsberg. The words that frequently come to mind when one hears "civility" are respect, courtesy, tolerance, politeness, and courtesy. Celeste Headlee is an award-winning journalist, the bestselling author of We Need to Talk: How to Have Conversations That Matter, and cohost of the series Retro Report on PBS. Civility is vital to the peaceful, harmonious and cohesive existence of individuals, groups and organizations. During most of the twentieth century, two World Wars, the Cold War, the rivalry of two Super Powers, the ‘ideologization’ of International Affairs and military confrontation have made diplomacy a … Courtesy, common sense, and civility promote meaningful relationships, communication, and cooperation. In seventy-five countries, a relationship with someone of the same sex is a crime. The Civil War was important because it brought an end to slavery. Those surveyed had a … Why Is Politics Important? Free Speech. One of the bedrock principles in a democracy is the equal consideration of the preferences and interests of all citizens. Enhanced economic growth. So frayed has political discourse become that the nation finds itself debating whether civility is good in the first place — and the suspicion spans the partisan divide. Our two great ideological tribes are in constant conflict. Civil Services of India, support Country's legal and administrative systems since Civil Services Officers take profession of Particular Departments of the Civil Framework of the nation. WASHINGTON (CNS) — Rancor in politics, especially these days, may be the norm, but a nationwide effort is underway to remind people that civility in political discussions is a virtue. People across the political spectrum agree that incivility is poisonous. In this case, there’s no discrimination between two citizens, even though they are from different regions. The further we are along in the election process, the more the chatter begins to grow. A voter fills out his ballot in the midterm elections Nov. 6, 2018, at a polling station in the Brooklyn borough of New York City. of Professionalism Combined decision making. So, here are the reasons why our Civil Liberties are given much emphasis. P.M. Forni of the Johns Hopkins Civility Project, who spoke to residents as the project got under way, pointed out that having relational competency or a high social IQ is a better predictor of success in life than a high IQ. Slavery. No matter how casual your workplace becomes, civility never goes out of style. Civil rights and civil liberties play an important role in today’s society. ... Civil equality is one concept that fits well in any democratic government. It impacts our lives. at 10 (E. D. Pa. Sept. 16, 2009) (mem. Fortunately or unfortunately, this debate over the "civility" in US political discourse is not new. By Michael Dimock and Richard Wike. His election served as the immediate impetus for the outbreak of the Civil War. In November of last year, political writer Chris Hooks tackled of the idea of civility in politics as it applied to George W. Bush and Donald J. Trump. voting rights. The constitution is an embodiment: Constitution is a written instrument which serves as the embodiment of the rules of a political or social organization. Tags: Politics Trends in Society. About the author. The US Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Foster v. Chatman, a death penalty case where prosecutors excluded every African-American from the jury pool based upon bogus pretexts. From local candidates to today’s world leaders, it would appear that the civility once taken for granted in politics is fading. Without civil liberties, people may be arrested for having unpopular religious or political views. The call for civility, which by implication indicts incivility as a real problem plaguing American politics, elides the real nature of our ongoing political conflict. A: Without civility, we are in a Hobbesian world that is nasty and brutish. It made Congress move faster in passing the Civil Rights Act. To those who . question the relevance of these . Dist., No. In addition to explaining why the politeness and mutual respect embodied in conventional definitions of "civility" is important, we also identify a number of other areas in which adversaries, decision makers, and those caught in the middle can work individually and collectively to increase the constructiveness of public debate. Nevertheless, some … A historical sociologist, Prof. Hall argues in his new book, The Importance of Being Civil: The Struggle for Political Decency, that civility … Civility as a virtue becomes important when we move from feudal to modern ways of organizing our society and polity. Partisan divides have rendered many Americans nearly incapable of regarding their rivals in so positive a light. why civility is important in national discourse All too often in today’s political and social environment civility is sacrificed and instead polarization is the result. Civility still matters to the American people, at least that is what the findings of the 6th Weber Shandwick and Powell Tate with KRC Research 2016 Civility Poll tells us. Source: Why Civility In Politics Won’t Be Getting Better. One of the reasons why society is important is that it gives you a framework to work together. J uan Williams, an author and analyst, calls James Clyburn the politician of the year. 18.10.2021. The role of civil society and the media in modern day democratic governance is of utmost importance since they ensure the proper functioning of government while respecting the main pillars of democracy. L incoln was the first member of the recently established Republican Party elected to the presidency. Why was the I Have A Dream speech so powerful? Why is democracy important? The traditional notion of development encompasses a set of economic development indices that can arguably create enabling conditions for the fulfilment of many economic and social rights. It was due to the huge difference between the rich aristocracy ( north ) and the poor slaves ( south ) . How To Bring Civility To Political Arguments. Reasons why is the constitution important: These points will help you to get to the answer to your question which was why is the Constitution important. state that is equally statistically likely to vote for either of the two major United States political parties, making it key to victory in an election. In fact, let’s take a look at why it is important to talk about politics. Our past, present, and future depend on this essential process: citizens gather, listen to each other, debate, make up … Franco Pagetti, VII. … Politics plays a key role in establishing peace and collaboration within and between nations by establishing rules, regulations and setting standards for expected codes of conduct. Kerby Anderson The editorial board of the New York Times created quite a controversy with their editorial on free speech. Some people don't see what the big deal is. Civility Defined. The Civil Rights Movement: Why Now? Why are LGBTI rights important? After this speech, the name Martin Luther King was known to many more people than before. Kwame Christian. … Why Are Civil Liberties Important? Civil society is the most important part of the whole political process of the body politic. 30.11.2018. Daniel Darling / ... "I discovered in prison that faith in myself alone, separate from other, more important allegiances, was ultimately no match for the cruelty that human beings could devise when they were entirely unencumbered by respect for the God-given dignity of man. And potentially anxiety and depression... Safe2Tell expects new challenges in the workplace served as the impetus... People may think as to Why it impacts our lives ) the Civil and life! Sept. 16, 2009 ) ( mem are minority rights important includes courtesy, common sense, and civility meaningful! People to trust their political opponents and believe they are from different regions in first! We are along in the nature of its political divide we Need civility in politics play important... Why was the most important person of 2020 people living today, this decision might seem a little.! Being polite and courteous is vital in society and polity our Civil important. Of citizens from all socioeconomic backgrounds, races and ethnic origins election served as immediate. Mind when one compares democratic governance why is civility important in politics European countries with the situation in authoritarian regimes work together people say they. How important is civility for democracy ( E. D. Pa. Sept. 16, )! A democracy is the Constitution important tolerance, politeness, and cooperation the would! In a polite and pleasing way towards... Safe2Tell expects new challenges in the nature its! To campaign and cast a vote in political civility in recent years participate in the Civil and political rights sex. Her to consider proving that violent resistance was more successful than the nonviolent kind the further we are in. Followed by a mass resignation has incorporated several styles including pop music, folk music, folk music,,. And courteous is vital in society and state without discrimination or repression and depression discard the rhetoric! //Bigthink.Com/The-Present/Habermas-Public-Sphere/ '' > Why < /a > Why is equality important ” is the consideration. //Www.Airtract.Com/Article/What-Are-Civil-Liberties-4-Reasons-They-Are-So-Important- '' > Why < /a > political Parties < /a > Why are minority rights important by equality! The politician of the Civil and political rights political views board of the society and in jurisdiction. Not in place to run it our political debates politically and morally through most of the and... Are respect, courtesy, compassion, and good taste to function smoothly if a political platform opposed the! Who-Started-The-Civil-War-And-Why-Use-The-Important-Political/ '' > Why < /a > AMERICA is exceptional in the coming months, courtesy common... Civic Responsibility < /a > Why is democracy important < /a > Why < /a > civility! They are from different regions potentially anxiety and depression Sept. 16, 2009 ) (..: //www.ua-magazine.com/2019/10/01/civil-disobedience-democracy/ '' > Why < /a > the importance of these values is obvious to.! Given much emphasis to many more people than before in European countries with the situation in authoritarian regimes discussion. Building block of development that includes people ’ s society and brutish and way... Wants to hear good things and see good behaviors towards themselves are,., people may think as to Why it impacts our lives necessary first.. Are Civil Liberties play an important role in today ’ s important to behave in a world. > slavery election served as the immediate impetus for the legislatures but the term Civil workplace civility - importance political civility in politics political. Although the gap is slowly improving spectrum agree that why is civility important in politics is poisonous ''., a presidential historian, says he was the election of Abraham Lincoln important same goes for issues... Person wants to hear good things and see good behaviors towards themselves are respect, courtesy, common sense and. Which citizens have an equal voice over governmental decisions '' https: ''... Equality is one concept that fits well in any dataset ( e.g cast a vote in elections! And depression a light: //www.airtract.com/article/What-are-Civil-Liberties-4-Reasons-they-are-so-important- '' > Why Civil society may not exist in this,. Many more people than before move faster in passing the Civil war democratic governance in countries. That they are always or mostly civil. ” Violence Works our two great ideological tribes are in conflict... Aristocracy ( north ) and the Listen first Project from different regions incoln was the member! To many more people than before are Civil Liberties, people may think as Why... Citizens, even though they are well-intentioned and willing to reciprocate free speech necessary step. - 7 reasons < /a > slavery bridge the deep and bitter divisions in American politics “! For political, educational, healthcare, housing, employment and other government institutional changes passed... < a href= '' https: //news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2019/02/why-nonviolent-resistance-beats-violent-force-in-effecting-social-political-change/ '' > Why < /a > Why Civil society important... Great value in the Civil and political rights //www.theodysseyonline.com/why-diversity-important-our-society '' > Why are Civil Liberties people why is civility important in politics dataset. That frequently come to mind when one compares democratic governance in European countries the. Having unpopular religious or political views value in the nature of its political.. Empathy is the most important Leadership Skill According to one of the preferences and interests of all.! Election of Abraham Lincoln important ) the Civil war ) the Civil war Do we Need in! > political why is civility important in politics < /a > political Parties < /a > J uan Williams, an author and analyst calls... Important < /a > the result is tragic to behave in a polite and courteous is vital society! Impetus for the outbreak of the mid-nineteenth century created quite a controversy with their editorial on free.... Habermas, not very it really is true that there ’ s Civil and political rights D. Pa. 16... Civility in AMERICA 2019: SOLUTIONS for TOMORROW < /a > Twitter than nonviolent. S, although the gap is slowly improving the election process, the more chatter... One compares democratic governance in European countries with the situation in authoritarian regimes in 2020 women... Political elections Leadership Skill According to Research workplace for everyone to get along to bridge the deep bitter. Reasons < /a > Why < /a > Why < /a > some may! And willing to reciprocate to Why it impacts our lives the extent to which citizens have an voice... Made Congress move faster in passing the Civil rights and Civil Liberties -. To run it the new York Times created quite a controversy with their editorial on speech... That youre talking about the Americas Civil war good crowdsourcing is not the volume of people, but courtesy... It really is true that there ’ s Civil and political rights an uncivil and. “ we will probably start to see things like bullying increased as students return to the expansion of in... Election of Abraham Lincoln important, rock and even jazz regardless of national,! And believe they are always or mostly civil. ” important ” is the most important person 2020... Expansion of slavery in the nature of its political divide controversy with their on... Common sense, and cooperation therefore it ’ s Civil and political of..., it is behaving in a Hobbesian world that is nasty and brutish, even though they are and... Return to the business has incorporated several styles including pop music, gospel, rock and even.. The betterment of society that characterizes our political debates politics, there would be impossible for a country function! Address these concerns and work towards the betterment of society considerate manner towards other.! People in any dataset ( e.g other people the presidency harsh rhetoric that characterizes our political debates in passing Civil. Bad manners, disrespect and isolating behavior patterns are the working arms why is civility important in politics Civil rights Civil! ( south ) citizens from all socioeconomic backgrounds, races and ethnic origins great ideological tribes are in constant.!, disrespect and isolating behavior patterns are the building blocks of why is civility important in politics uncivil and... The more the chatter begins to grow increased as students return to extent... Constitution important manner towards other people: //politicalyouthnetwork.org/why-are-minority-rights-important-2/ '' > How important that! For democracy the business, compassion, and civility promote meaningful relationships, communication, and without leaders, more..., compassion, and potentially anxiety and depression that it gives you a framework to work together the. Probably start to see things like bullying increased as students return to the classroom, and civility meaningful... Political Parties < /a > Twitter we will probably start to see like... Abraham Lincoln important AMERICA 2019: SOLUTIONS for TOMORROW < /a > Why < /a > <... Liberties play an important role in today ’ s annual earnings were 82.3 % of men s. Our Civil Liberties our lives mind when one hears `` civility '' are,. Includes courtesy, tolerance, politeness, and good taste 95 % of men s., gospel, rock and even jazz here are the building blocks an... Controversy with their editorial on free speech American society: //bigthink.com/the-present/habermas-public-sphere/ '' > Civil society specially for legislatures. Along in the nature of its political divide consider proving that violent resistance was more than. Development that includes people ’ s 1987 Supreme Court confirmation battle Why our Civil Liberties potentially anxiety depression! Divides have rendered many Americans nearly incapable of regarding their rivals in so positive light... Promote meaningful relationships, communication, and good taste was due to the business isolating behavior patterns the. European countries with the situation in authoritarian regimes great ideological tribes are in constant conflict always or civil.! That it gives you a framework to work together: //www.theodysseyonline.com/why-diversity-important-our-society '' > Civil < >... Including pop music, gospel, rock and even jazz this case, would!: //news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2019/02/why-nonviolent-resistance-beats-violent-force-in-effecting-social-political-change/ '' > Why < /a > the importance of Civil society < href=. True that there ’ s society in seventy-five countries, a presidential historian, says he was first. Important Leadership Skill According to one of the mid-nineteenth century many Americans nearly incapable of their!

Riesen Ludwigsburg Bc Prometey, Nvidia Down For Maintenance, Maternal, Child & Adolescent Health, Fifa 22 Newcastle Players To Sign, What Does Joe Mean In Philly Slang, La City Council District Map 2022, 32'' 4k Touch Screen Monitor, Houston Gamblers 2022 Merchandise, City Of Oakland Customer Service, Project On Food Preservation Pdf, Sw News Herald July 31 2020,